I was thinking more of Schubert and his amazing masterpiece "Rosamunde."
Like AOS, the play that Schubert wrote that music for bombed and closed in a week, but the music lived on. Like in AOS, the melodies are riveting in Rosamunde.
Saying the melodies in AOS are "riveting" is overselling them. Most of them, IMHO, are pretty good, but not ESPECIALLY noteworthy, and certainly not "riveting". And there's at least one song that is dissonant, painful to listen to, and calling it "mediocre" would be generous.
Now there’s a man who truly understands the robot dance.
Is it irony that the topic is “renewed mind” while the motion depicts a brainwashed state?
Truly, truly stated....but wait...I found robot boy's newst project....I was inresidence with him...not a bad guy...terribly conceited but otherwise, decent folks.
Truly, truly stated....but wait...I found robot boy's newst project....I was inresidence with him...not a bad guy...terribly conceited but otherwise, decent folks.
All scripture is profitable — if you try hard enough.
On 7/19/2023 at 8:44 PM, Nathan_Jr said:
an opportunity to teach on criticism -- criticism of film, music, architecture, food, coffee... whatever.
Good prompt for self reflection. It’s easy to confuse my preferences with objectivity. Reminds me of an indie folk guy who was listening to and rating new releases. One song was from a prominent pop artist. And his response was “it’s not for me.”
The funny thing is, I enjoy most other songs by that artist — but not the one he was given. I thought, he probably would like anything else. But my response would have been “this is not good.”
All scripture is profitable — if you try hard enough.
If you try hard enough you can MAKE it fit.
5 hours ago, Logicisgreatstuff said:
Good prompt for self reflection. It’s easy to confuse my preferences with objectivity. Reminds me of an indie folk guy who was listening to and rating new releases. One song was from a prominent pop artist. And his response was “it’s not for me.”
The funny thing is, I enjoy most other songs by that artist — but not the one he was given. I thought, he probably would like anything else. But my response would have been “this is not good.”
I can appreciate various genres of music, but I separate my appreciation from my preference, though sometimes they are aligned. Some of my favorite music could not be considered great. Jerry Garcia was NOT a great vocalist, the quality of the band's performances were inconsistent, often abysmal, and it could be argued that they never really improved, though they had decades to do so. But I love the Grateful Dead's music, nonetheless.
Classical music and Jazz played a big part in the soundtrack of my youth, because that's what my dad liked and it was ALWAYS playing in the house. To compare the music of AOS with great classical composers, to call it one the greatest compositions of the 20th century, strikes me as an opinion from someone who has never listened to great music nor tried to understand what makes great music.
As the logical errors literally leap off the pages of PFAL and the collaterals, so do the pretentious affectations of AOS. It is cringe. It's not for me.
The lake of fire is just a figger of speech illustrating with mathematical exactness the literal meaning, according to usage, of the scene I described.
The lake of fire is just a figger of speech illustrating with mathematical exactness the literal meaning, according to usage, of the scene I described.
The white horse will be saddled with bags filled with the collaterals. Jesus will teach from PFAL. And the music of AOS will provide the soundtrack.
Is crossing Plaffy with the book of Revelation the equivalent to a new kind of designer drug?
What you describe sounds like a really bad trip on a designer drug. I mean so bad you have the potential for Teletubbies appearing riding purple dinosaurs.
I mean this would be what we are trying to rescue Mikey from as it sounds downright frightening.
Saying the melodies in AOS are "riveting" is overselling them. Most of them, IMHO, are pretty good, but not ESPECIALLY noteworthy, and certainly not "riveting". And there's at least one song that is dissonant, painful to listen to, and calling it "mediocre" would be generous.
I mean “riveting” could mean a train wreck catching your attention.
Cue the Way Orchestra and the little riffs going on - men in tights doing the jock shuffle to represent SIT.
Then slowly a group of 20 strippers emerges all doing a pole dance routine without the pole.
Then the jock puts the seed ladies foot on his shoulder and gazes into her eyes. Then she collapses into his arms.
I mean it’s totally understandable why John Travolta and Scientology had to try and duplicate that on Staying Alive 2.
Cue the Way Orchestra and the little riffs going on - men in tights doing the jock shuffle to represent SIT.
I was not so unfortunate to have bonded my eyes to the visuals in AOS. I think I got the cassette tape before seeing the video. But for sure, I only saw the video once, and then heard the cassette music MANY TIMES on my walkman while working.
I got an unbiased hearing of the music; I understand your visual handicap in this matter.
Since then I have only looked at brief minutes of the video in recent years. Once maybe twice in 38 years.
I was not so unfortunate to have bonded my eyes to the visuals in AOS. I think I got the cassette tape before seeing the video. But for sure, I only saw the video once, and then heard the cassette music MANY TIMES on my walkman while working.
I got an unbiased hearing of the music; I understand your handicap.
Forgive me if my view is that cleaning windows with headphones on and AOS orchestra in the background clearly represents way more of a handicap than I have ever dealt with.
Recommended Posts
Top Posters In This Topic
12
13
13
12
Popular Days
Jul 25
18
Jul 26
18
Jul 19
12
Jul 21
10
Top Posters In This Topic
Rocky 12 posts
Mike 13 posts
OldSkool 13 posts
Nathan_Jr 12 posts
Popular Days
Jul 25 2023
18 posts
Jul 26 2023
18 posts
Jul 19 2023
12 posts
Jul 21 2023
10 posts
Popular Posts
waysider
If the leotard fits, you must do the splits.
WordWolf
Even JAL noticed that- for something supposedly explaining spiritual stuff- it has time for 2 hours of fluff but nowhere in the production is JESUS CHRIST himself invited to be a part of things. Who
Nathan_Jr
Viktorpneustos
Posted Images
WordWolf
Saying the melodies in AOS are "riveting" is overselling them. Most of them, IMHO, are pretty good, but not ESPECIALLY noteworthy, and certainly not "riveting". And there's at least one song that is dissonant, painful to listen to, and calling it "mediocre" would be generous.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
chockfull
Now there’s a man who truly understands the robot dance.
Is it irony that the topic is “renewed mind” while the motion depicts a brainwashed state?
Link to comment
Share on other sites
OldSkool
Truly, truly stated....but wait...I found robot boy's newst project....I was inresidence with him...not a bad guy...terribly conceited but otherwise, decent folks.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
waysider
Well, ya know, it's spirchal, so it's more like Astroboy.
Go! Go! Go! Astroboy!
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Rocky
Ewww! Talk about brainwashing!
Link to comment
Share on other sites
OldSkool
Right!! Creeepy no? And we feed our children this sor of thing....
Link to comment
Share on other sites
OldSkool
Dude, thatnks for posting that...I love old cartoons like this one..too funny!
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Rocky
Creeepy YES!
Link to comment
Share on other sites
penworks
Sounds like a question for Walt*r Cumm*ns, the one VPW put in charge of "biblical research."
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Rocky
LOL! As if anyone could overcome Victor Wierwille's domineering malignant narcissism.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Logicisgreatstuff
All scripture is profitable — if you try hard enough.
Good prompt for self reflection. It’s easy to confuse my preferences with objectivity. Reminds me of an indie folk guy who was listening to and rating new releases. One song was from a prominent pop artist. And his response was “it’s not for me.”
The funny thing is, I enjoy most other songs by that artist — but not the one he was given. I thought, he probably would like anything else. But my response would have been “this is not good.”
Link to comment
Share on other sites
waysider
Brutal!
Link to comment
Share on other sites
So_crates
The questions are rhetorical.
Part of what I was attempting to do was getting at another presupposition: The Way has the Word of God.
Does The Way have the Word of God?
How do we know?
If The Way has the Word of God, why don't people act like it or follow it's dictates?
This, of course, goes along with the other two presuppositions which were never answered:
Was Saint Vic a MOG?
How do we know?
Did Saint Vic work for God?
Again, how do we know?
Edited by So_cratesLink to comment
Share on other sites
Nathan_Jr
If you try hard enough you can MAKE it fit.
I can appreciate various genres of music, but I separate my appreciation from my preference, though sometimes they are aligned. Some of my favorite music could not be considered great. Jerry Garcia was NOT a great vocalist, the quality of the band's performances were inconsistent, often abysmal, and it could be argued that they never really improved, though they had decades to do so. But I love the Grateful Dead's music, nonetheless.
Classical music and Jazz played a big part in the soundtrack of my youth, because that's what my dad liked and it was ALWAYS playing in the house. To compare the music of AOS with great classical composers, to call it one the greatest compositions of the 20th century, strikes me as an opinion from someone who has never listened to great music nor tried to understand what makes great music.
As the logical errors literally leap off the pages of PFAL and the collaterals, so do the pretentious affectations of AOS. It is cringe. It's not for me.
Edited by Nathan_JrGloves
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Rocky
To each question, I would reply, ye shall know them by their fruit.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
So_crates
To which I'd firmly agree.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Nathan_Jr
The white horse will be saddled with bags filled with the collaterals. Jesus will teach from PFAL. And the music of AOS will provide the soundtrack.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
OldSkool
And I'll happily go swimming in the lake of fire....
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Nathan_Jr
The lake of fire is just a figger of speech illustrating with mathematical exactness the literal meaning, according to usage, of the scene I described.
Gloves
Link to comment
Share on other sites
OldSkool
Lo Shantu Deeshy malatov loktail....
Link to comment
Share on other sites
chockfull
Is crossing Plaffy with the book of Revelation the equivalent to a new kind of designer drug?
What you describe sounds like a really bad trip on a designer drug. I mean so bad you have the potential for Teletubbies appearing riding purple dinosaurs.
I mean this would be what we are trying to rescue Mikey from as it sounds downright frightening.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
chockfull
I mean “riveting” could mean a train wreck catching your attention.
Cue the Way Orchestra and the little riffs going on - men in tights doing the jock shuffle to represent SIT.
Then slowly a group of 20 strippers emerges all doing a pole dance routine without the pole.
Then the jock puts the seed ladies foot on his shoulder and gazes into her eyes. Then she collapses into his arms.
I mean it’s totally understandable why John Travolta and Scientology had to try and duplicate that on Staying Alive 2.
It’s so……. so……..
Riveting
lol
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Mike
I was not so unfortunate to have bonded my eyes to the visuals in AOS. I think I got the cassette tape before seeing the video. But for sure, I only saw the video once, and then heard the cassette music MANY TIMES on my walkman while working.
I got an unbiased hearing of the music; I understand your visual handicap in this matter.
Since then I have only looked at brief minutes of the video in recent years. Once maybe twice in 38 years.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
chockfull
Forgive me if my view is that cleaning windows with headphones on and AOS orchestra in the background clearly represents way more of a handicap than I have ever dealt with.
You are in my prayers.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.