welcome to the cafe longgone...i admire your courage to tell this part of your story here.
and while i cant say i feel quite the way you do about danger and loss being associated with bible and prayer...i at least want to respond to let you know i read your post...and otherwise offer my witness. I am have experienced my share of danger and loss regardless of my relationship to the bible and prayer. Also, the danger and loss that can often come with expressing one's spirituality in conventional world.
i would be interested in hearing about how you commune with God...if only to break bread with a fellow traveler.
i can certainly relate to the loneliness and isolation of being a spiritual seeker...and an investigator of the interior life. I relate more to the desert fathers and mothers of Christianity than modern mainstream church life.
as such...a few things i can ask/suggest...
have you looked into other forms of spiritual counsel that are not as superstitious as the one you described...not as much about fixing as they are about listening and friendship? Quaker friendship practices come to mind. Also, a good "spiritual director" from the catholic tradition can help. Both are more about helping you hear your self into deeper awareness than they are about fixing.
also, if you are a reader, perhaps you might look into the notion of the "dark night of the soul" by "Saint" John of the Cross. His writings and experiences deal with the spiritual growth that comes from the in-between times of not knowing.
i am not catholic, nor do i lump all catholics into the same boat. Ive met too many monks and nuns that defy the stereotypes...and are not hung up on dogmatism.
there is something rich and authentic and wise about the contemplative and monastic Christian world that applies directly to "being alone together"...many arts and practices developed specifically for the inner life. 2 millenia of Christian history has generated a diverse range of effective prayer practices that are often overlooked by american protestantism.
also...if you are concerned about the danger that comes with getting closer to the christian bible...have you considered the jewish traditions? not as a belief system, but as another lineage rich with arts and wisdom that also deals with the inner life....stages of life...aging...etc...
or even a step further...buddhist or other eastern lineages? they are also rich with wisdom and actual practices for communing with the divine, finding answers, and basically helping find clarity on our paths. Ive seen too much to say they are dangerous or contrary to christianity.
but also again...i am not an official member of any of these religions. But nor do i lump them all in some flat equalizing way. Within each are depths and degrees of qualities of practices and experience. While they all seem rooted in common ground...there are also differences worth appreciating.
i wish you luck in your search. thanks again for sharing your conundrum here.
Life sure can throw some weird stuff in your direction when you're not looking.
I don't usually try to assign too much deep meaning to any of it, though.
Maybe that's just how I am.
There was another poster here with the same handle a few years ago. He later changed his screen name to LG. I'm sorry to say, he passed away some time ago.
I'm looking forward to your contribution to this wacky place we call GSC.
Thanks for the pie. Yeah, not attaching too much meaning to any of life's weirdness is probably pretty good advice. And I think that's how I've been taking things for quite a while now. It was just odd to find that little fear still waiting in my brain when I decided to poke around this site again. But there is probably not a better answer what you suggest. So, far there have been no disasters worse than leaky faucets.
I'd hoped to be able to contribute something helpful but as I consider your original thread and understand it more, I hope, I can only add that I think life is like that sometimes.
We get up every morning and do the best we can, do our best to make sound decisions and choices that aren't going to purposely hurt other people or ourselves and put head to pillow hoping it all went ok and we get another shot at it in the morning.
I include you in our prayers around here and hope that your answers are received. Hang out here if you want to and glean what works for you, toss what doesn't. For YOU!
Thanks for a very thoughtful reply. Funny you mention Catholic resources. I've been caring for my 90 year old mom for a few years now. She's a Catholic and in an effort to find things that will entertain and interest her we've read a few books and watched a bunch of movies about Catholic saints. I do find much that is inspiring and helpful in the lives of the saints. St. Theresa the Little Flower and her "Story of A Soul" has been very helpful to me while I find it necessary to let go of more and more of myself as my mother needs more and more from me. Other saints whose stories have moved me much are St. Francis of Assisi, St. John Bosco of Turin and St. Rita of Cascia.
My mom was in the habit of reading meditations and Catholic prayers every day. Now that it's become too difficult for her to focus all the way through them by herself I've begun to do her readings and recite her prayers with her. I don't really "pray", just read the prayers for and with her. But I've come to appreciate the beauty of the prayers and many of the meditations.
I don't think I would call the spirituality that I experience a "communion with God". It's more about having and expressing compassion and mercy, seeing the beauty that is around me and allowing it to feed me, being able to comfort and understand. I love St. Therese's "Little Way". I try to do the things I do with love and concern. I've learned to experience joy in letting go of myself for the sake of others. I don't find the concept of God necessary to achieve any of these things to the level that I need them in my life. If wanted to be a canonized saint one day - I'd probably need more than what I can achieve from within myself. But to simply be a contented and satisfied average human being, I can find these resources in myself.
If I'm wrong and God must exist and be at work in a man's life in order for him to have these qualities, then He must be willing to do it anonymously for me.
Thanks for the suggestions. I'll keep the list in case I do regain an appetite some day. But I'm still full from all the reading I did when I was trying to learn more about God. I can't swallow even one thin spiritual mint. I couldn't say that I'm really searching anymore. Just living. But I might take a look at St. John of the Cross. Since I've seen how many Catholic saints went for years and years feeling that God was absent from some part of their lives, it's made me think more about the years when it seemed like He just wasn't interested in addressing the things that caused me so much pain. I'm curious about the journeys of those faithful. But, for myself - since I don't want to be a "saint" - I think if I ever have another Dark Night of the Soul, I'll just start taking Prozac again. It worked much better for me than a decade of prayer.
Your suggestion about Judaism is interesting too. I heard someone say the other day that Judaism is about what you do. What you believe is not as important. While Christianity places a great emphasis on beliefs. No matter what one does, one can't be a Christian without believing certain essentials. I don't worry myself much anymore about what I believe. I just try to do what seems right and do it well.
I'm glad to have a place like this to air out this part of my life. I guess I'm feeling a need to revisit something that has been packed away for a while. It will be interesting to see where it goes. Thanks for your thoughts.
We get up every morning and do the best we can, do our best to make sound decisions and choices that aren't going to purposely hurt other people or ourselves and put head to pillow hoping it all went ok and we get another shot at it in the morning."
Shellon,
Thanks. That really does sum it up pretty well. And if I wrote it on napkin it would be easier to carry around than a bunch of research books too.
Is this some of those coincidences that just happen? You know, like when you first learned to pray, and then when what you prayed for happened, you attributed it to God. And if it didn't happen you either attributed it to your own "lack of believing" or to "the adversary."
Now it's happening the other way round, are you attributing things that just happen randomly to pulling out your Bible again?
You've certainly had some unpleasant things happen to you, though.
If reading your Bible is not bringing peace to you - don't read it. God looks on the heart - not on the "works" of spending time reading just because you feel you ought to.
Get out there and live what you know, give what you can, and speak when spoken to...if asked.
And enjoy the time you have with your mum. It's good, what you're doing with her. And maybe it's God's way of helping you, too.
Thanks for your reply. This certainly is the best time of my life. Some personal breakthroughs that I've never been able to manage under any circumstances have finally become possible in this situation. And I know there is more to come.
Coincidences happen. As waysider and Shellon have suggested, maybe stuff just happens and it's not worthwhile to attach too much meaning. I've certainly experienced loss and some danger since I stopped thinking about God all the time too. But, it's been clearer to me where it's coming from when it does. I mean I can see that I've actually put myself at risk somehow or that there is a set of circumstances that explains my experience. Maybe I just see things more clearly because I'm not always looking through God glasses.
You know I don't think I really believe in some magic thing that might happen if I let myself study or pray. I just think that maybe there is something about me as a person that functions better through a different kind of filter.
I don't have any great words of wisdom with what you posted but do thank you for sharing. I have been through things in my life where I have attributed them to my stand on the word as well but not like you have shared here. I mean there is that verse about those who live godly = suffering persecution but I honestly believe we can't live our lives trying to associate every bad thing to that because we then may turn from God himself and or forget to see the good that He brings our way. I don't read like I use to. I have just chosen to love God my way and talk with him with no pressure to believe this or that. I adhere to the good and simple things like being kind and honest and let God teach me as I go along whatever He thinks I need to know and along with trusting He will do that I trust him to protect me if any harm should come my way for my beliefs. If He doesn't it is what it is and He'll sort it out in the end. :)
Thanks for taking the time to read and reply. I think it has helped me to just throw this stuff out to this group and to discuss it a little. I especially liked what you said;
"If He doesn't it is what it is and He'll sort it out in the end."
The freedom to accept life as it comes is one thing that TWI wrong teaching really interfered with. In a previous reply Sirguessalot brought up the Catholic teachings along those lines. It's been helpful for me to hear about the lives of people with deep faith, and the actions to prove it, who went for years even decades without understanding why things were the way they were or even feeling separated from God in one way or another for long periods. Yet somehow this did not lessen their faith but rather increased it. I'm often put off by the degree of self sacrifice and suffering these individuals accepted and even sought out - but still I got the point, that you don't have to understand it for it to be OK. And it doesn't have to all work out rosy for it to be good.
Recommended Posts
sirguessalot
welcome to the cafe longgone...i admire your courage to tell this part of your story here.
and while i cant say i feel quite the way you do about danger and loss being associated with bible and prayer...i at least want to respond to let you know i read your post...and otherwise offer my witness. I am have experienced my share of danger and loss regardless of my relationship to the bible and prayer. Also, the danger and loss that can often come with expressing one's spirituality in conventional world.
i would be interested in hearing about how you commune with God...if only to break bread with a fellow traveler.
i can certainly relate to the loneliness and isolation of being a spiritual seeker...and an investigator of the interior life. I relate more to the desert fathers and mothers of Christianity than modern mainstream church life.
as such...a few things i can ask/suggest...
have you looked into other forms of spiritual counsel that are not as superstitious as the one you described...not as much about fixing as they are about listening and friendship? Quaker friendship practices come to mind. Also, a good "spiritual director" from the catholic tradition can help. Both are more about helping you hear your self into deeper awareness than they are about fixing.
also, if you are a reader, perhaps you might look into the notion of the "dark night of the soul" by "Saint" John of the Cross. His writings and experiences deal with the spiritual growth that comes from the in-between times of not knowing.
i am not catholic, nor do i lump all catholics into the same boat. Ive met too many monks and nuns that defy the stereotypes...and are not hung up on dogmatism.
there is something rich and authentic and wise about the contemplative and monastic Christian world that applies directly to "being alone together"...many arts and practices developed specifically for the inner life. 2 millenia of Christian history has generated a diverse range of effective prayer practices that are often overlooked by american protestantism.
also...if you are concerned about the danger that comes with getting closer to the christian bible...have you considered the jewish traditions? not as a belief system, but as another lineage rich with arts and wisdom that also deals with the inner life....stages of life...aging...etc...
or even a step further...buddhist or other eastern lineages? they are also rich with wisdom and actual practices for communing with the divine, finding answers, and basically helping find clarity on our paths. Ive seen too much to say they are dangerous or contrary to christianity.
but also again...i am not an official member of any of these religions. But nor do i lump them all in some flat equalizing way. Within each are depths and degrees of qualities of practices and experience. While they all seem rooted in common ground...there are also differences worth appreciating.
i wish you luck in your search. thanks again for sharing your conundrum here.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
waysider
Hey there, longgone
Life sure can throw some weird stuff in your direction when you're not looking.
I don't usually try to assign too much deep meaning to any of it, though.
Maybe that's just how I am.
There was another poster here with the same handle a few years ago. He later changed his screen name to LG. I'm sorry to say, he passed away some time ago.
I'm looking forward to your contribution to this wacky place we call GSC.
Hope you like lemon meringue.
(It's on the house.)
Link to comment
Share on other sites
longgone
Waysider,
Thanks for the pie. Yeah, not attaching too much meaning to any of life's weirdness is probably pretty good advice. And I think that's how I've been taking things for quite a while now. It was just odd to find that little fear still waiting in my brain when I decided to poke around this site again. But there is probably not a better answer what you suggest. So, far there have been no disasters worse than leaky faucets.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Shellon
I'd hoped to be able to contribute something helpful but as I consider your original thread and understand it more, I hope, I can only add that I think life is like that sometimes.
We get up every morning and do the best we can, do our best to make sound decisions and choices that aren't going to purposely hurt other people or ourselves and put head to pillow hoping it all went ok and we get another shot at it in the morning.
I include you in our prayers around here and hope that your answers are received. Hang out here if you want to and glean what works for you, toss what doesn't. For YOU!
Link to comment
Share on other sites
longgone
sirguessalot,
Thanks for a very thoughtful reply. Funny you mention Catholic resources. I've been caring for my 90 year old mom for a few years now. She's a Catholic and in an effort to find things that will entertain and interest her we've read a few books and watched a bunch of movies about Catholic saints. I do find much that is inspiring and helpful in the lives of the saints. St. Theresa the Little Flower and her "Story of A Soul" has been very helpful to me while I find it necessary to let go of more and more of myself as my mother needs more and more from me. Other saints whose stories have moved me much are St. Francis of Assisi, St. John Bosco of Turin and St. Rita of Cascia.
My mom was in the habit of reading meditations and Catholic prayers every day. Now that it's become too difficult for her to focus all the way through them by herself I've begun to do her readings and recite her prayers with her. I don't really "pray", just read the prayers for and with her. But I've come to appreciate the beauty of the prayers and many of the meditations.
I don't think I would call the spirituality that I experience a "communion with God". It's more about having and expressing compassion and mercy, seeing the beauty that is around me and allowing it to feed me, being able to comfort and understand. I love St. Therese's "Little Way". I try to do the things I do with love and concern. I've learned to experience joy in letting go of myself for the sake of others. I don't find the concept of God necessary to achieve any of these things to the level that I need them in my life. If wanted to be a canonized saint one day - I'd probably need more than what I can achieve from within myself. But to simply be a contented and satisfied average human being, I can find these resources in myself.
If I'm wrong and God must exist and be at work in a man's life in order for him to have these qualities, then He must be willing to do it anonymously for me.
Thanks for the suggestions. I'll keep the list in case I do regain an appetite some day. But I'm still full from all the reading I did when I was trying to learn more about God. I can't swallow even one thin spiritual mint. I couldn't say that I'm really searching anymore. Just living. But I might take a look at St. John of the Cross. Since I've seen how many Catholic saints went for years and years feeling that God was absent from some part of their lives, it's made me think more about the years when it seemed like He just wasn't interested in addressing the things that caused me so much pain. I'm curious about the journeys of those faithful. But, for myself - since I don't want to be a "saint" - I think if I ever have another Dark Night of the Soul, I'll just start taking Prozac again. It worked much better for me than a decade of prayer.
Your suggestion about Judaism is interesting too. I heard someone say the other day that Judaism is about what you do. What you believe is not as important. While Christianity places a great emphasis on beliefs. No matter what one does, one can't be a Christian without believing certain essentials. I don't worry myself much anymore about what I believe. I just try to do what seems right and do it well.
I'm glad to have a place like this to air out this part of my life. I guess I'm feeling a need to revisit something that has been packed away for a while. It will be interesting to see where it goes. Thanks for your thoughts.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
longgone
"I think life is like that sometimes.
We get up every morning and do the best we can, do our best to make sound decisions and choices that aren't going to purposely hurt other people or ourselves and put head to pillow hoping it all went ok and we get another shot at it in the morning."
Shellon,
Thanks. That really does sum it up pretty well. And if I wrote it on napkin it would be easier to carry around than a bunch of research books too.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Shellon
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Twinky
Is this some of those coincidences that just happen? You know, like when you first learned to pray, and then when what you prayed for happened, you attributed it to God. And if it didn't happen you either attributed it to your own "lack of believing" or to "the adversary."
Now it's happening the other way round, are you attributing things that just happen randomly to pulling out your Bible again?
You've certainly had some unpleasant things happen to you, though.
If reading your Bible is not bringing peace to you - don't read it. God looks on the heart - not on the "works" of spending time reading just because you feel you ought to.
Get out there and live what you know, give what you can, and speak when spoken to...if asked.
And enjoy the time you have with your mum. It's good, what you're doing with her. And maybe it's God's way of helping you, too.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
longgone
Twinky,
Thanks for your reply. This certainly is the best time of my life. Some personal breakthroughs that I've never been able to manage under any circumstances have finally become possible in this situation. And I know there is more to come.
Coincidences happen. As waysider and Shellon have suggested, maybe stuff just happens and it's not worthwhile to attach too much meaning. I've certainly experienced loss and some danger since I stopped thinking about God all the time too. But, it's been clearer to me where it's coming from when it does. I mean I can see that I've actually put myself at risk somehow or that there is a set of circumstances that explains my experience. Maybe I just see things more clearly because I'm not always looking through God glasses.
You know I don't think I really believe in some magic thing that might happen if I let myself study or pray. I just think that maybe there is something about me as a person that functions better through a different kind of filter.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
grand-daughter
Hi Long,
I don't have any great words of wisdom with what you posted but do thank you for sharing. I have been through things in my life where I have attributed them to my stand on the word as well but not like you have shared here. I mean there is that verse about those who live godly = suffering persecution but I honestly believe we can't live our lives trying to associate every bad thing to that because we then may turn from God himself and or forget to see the good that He brings our way. I don't read like I use to. I have just chosen to love God my way and talk with him with no pressure to believe this or that. I adhere to the good and simple things like being kind and honest and let God teach me as I go along whatever He thinks I need to know and along with trusting He will do that I trust him to protect me if any harm should come my way for my beliefs. If He doesn't it is what it is and He'll sort it out in the end. :)
Link to comment
Share on other sites
longgone
grand-daughter,
Thanks for taking the time to read and reply. I think it has helped me to just throw this stuff out to this group and to discuss it a little. I especially liked what you said;
"If He doesn't it is what it is and He'll sort it out in the end."
The freedom to accept life as it comes is one thing that TWI wrong teaching really interfered with. In a previous reply Sirguessalot brought up the Catholic teachings along those lines. It's been helpful for me to hear about the lives of people with deep faith, and the actions to prove it, who went for years even decades without understanding why things were the way they were or even feeling separated from God in one way or another for long periods. Yet somehow this did not lessen their faith but rather increased it. I'm often put off by the degree of self sacrifice and suffering these individuals accepted and even sought out - but still I got the point, that you don't have to understand it for it to be OK. And it doesn't have to all work out rosy for it to be good.
I hope to read more of your story sometime.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.