This does not ring with compassion or sincere apology, but rather, with same-old, same-old.
Very much like damage control. No acknowledgment of plagiarism, just that TWI pointed the way.
And this: "The Way International stands out on the spectrum of Church history as an amazingly significant Christian movement." Time will tell. How significant will it be in 100 years time? Still it seems that TWI is getting the glory - not God.
I only have a few minutes, (home on a lunch break) but a cursory reading sent up some major red flags.
It sounds like he's doing damage control. This quote seemed odd to me:
The whole letter seems odd to me.
Is the same letter that JAL penned with JS, RD and some others? If so then he's being dishonest.
In the 2008 letter posted on the Web there's a link to the 1998 letter to which JAL is referring and was indeed written by him.
In it he discusses the 1987 letter that was written in conjunction with RD, TR, RB, and PL:
In February of 1987, in conjunction with Ralph Dubofsky, Tom Reahard, Robert Belt and my wife Pat, I participated in writing a 37-page letter that we sent first to the Trustees. In it we confronted them with God's Word as to where they were in error, and called for a meeting of leadership to get out in the open and resolve them biblically.
This does not ring with compassion or sincere apology, but rather, with same-old, same-old.
Very much like damage control. No acknowledgment of plagiarism, just that TWI pointed the way.
And this: "The Way International stands out on the spectrum of Church history as an amazingly significant Christian movement." Time will tell. How significant will it be in 100 years time? Still it seems that TWI is getting the glory - not God.
I only excerpted parts of the 2008 letter and in the whole letter he does acknowledge plagiarism, along with other abuses:
Yes, there was more doctrinal error than I ever realized while I was in TWI, and there was corresponding practical error
that became more evil than most of us involved ever imagined. Yes, many precious people were terribly abused.
Yes, there was dishonesty about Scripture, there was plagiarism, and there was rampant sexual sin,
all of which contributed to many people choosing to turn away from God and His Word.
But, it's like a head nod to the abuses: I [JAL] will acknowledge the abuses, so that I can minimize them and talk about how great VPW and TWI were.
It strikes me as discordant - that's why I'm not sure what to make of it.
I skimmed the letters - I couldn't make myself read them in their entirety. They still read like infomercial scripts, IMHO.
"TWI was great! And NOW we have the new, the improved, the best of the best..."
"BUT WAIT! If you act NOW you'll receive not one but TWO sets of Ginsu knives - at no extra charge!"
Also this jumped out at me:
Yes, there was more doctrinal error than I ever realized while I was in TWI, and there was corresponding practical error that became more evil than most of us involved ever imagined. Yes, many precious people were terribly abused. Yes, there was dishonesty about Scripture, there was plagiarism, and there was rampant sexual sin, all of which contributed to many people choosing to turn away from God and His Word. And as I realized these things, I did speak out about them, both publicly and privately, from 1987 until about 2000, after which TWI had marginalized itself in Christendom.
Ummmmm... wasn't JAL one who practiced this error himself?
I'm sorry. I'm just not interested in this "package."
Both John's seem to imply that Bullinger had it mostly correct despite being Trinitarian. JL includes differences from TWI in a link summarizing them with their books and CD's and DVD's teaching series. Both apologize for the sexual abuse that occured but Karen's attitude is not mentioned. In a private post to him, JL said that recent British teaching videos(ALPHA, Open Home/Open Bible, Reality) and materials from the United Methodist(Beginings, Christian Believer) and Saddleback's Foundations 101 are an improvement over what has been taught but still off on the Trinity and Jesus Christ being God disguised in human flesh. He , JS, KG and others from Spirit and Truth, Christian Family, Christian Outreach, Christian Research, and other splinter groups claim it was the filmed PFAL class that forced the denominations to counter it in the late 90's and early 21st Centuary with their "spin". They like the humor and laughter and the personal touch, but still claim that the Church of England, UMC, ELCA, Willow Creek, Lakewood Baptist(Joel Osteen), Saddleback,etc. still don't get it(that is "The Truth"). So much for both John's, Kevin, Wayne, Rochelle and the others. At least they now consider us as the ignorant/separated brethern in the Body of Christ and "tolerate/love" us and no longer want us dead(just misguided like tiny toddlers).ps KG refers to Mr. Gigou, not MS. Grasser.
... and other splinter groups claim it was the filmed PFAL class that forced the denominations to counter it in the late 90's and early 21st Centuary with their "spin".
Seems they want to inject themselves into the bigger Christian dogma competition scene to create more drama for their soap opera ...
I guess for those that think that is what it is all about .. go ahead and give them more money ...
"TWI was great! And NOW we have the new, the improved, the best of the best..."
"BUT WAIT! If you act NOW you'll receive not one but TWO sets of Ginsu knives - at no extra charge!"
Thanks for the laugh Dooj..
When I read this--(which is the first thing that made me gag)
I am compelled to propose why I think The Way International was (past tense), from a certain perspective, one of the
most significant movements in the history of the Christian Church.
juxtaposed against this
Yes, there was more doctrinal error than I ever realized while I was in TWI, and there was corresponding practical error that became more evil than most of us involved ever imagined. Yes, many precious people were terribly abused. Yes, there was dishonesty about Scripture, there was plagiarism, and there was rampant sexual sin, all of which contributed to many people choosing to turn away from God and His Word.
I had to wonder what planet he was from, if he was schizophrenic and off his medication ,or if like ex said He started doing some mind altering drugs...Maybe he got bit by hallucinagenic nose spiders hallucinations.
Even if someone somehow was able to stretch and distort history and reality enough to actually believe the first statement how on earth could you state the second one and still maintain the first unless you were severely imbalanced?
If its laden with doctrinal error, practical error, evil, abuse, dishonesty,palgairism and rampant sexual sin ,how can it be a significant christian movement at all, never mind one the most important in history?
Letters like that make me want to pull my hair out
Wellll ... all great "movements" involve a lot of sheeet ... :)
butt good point mstar ... and nice job of juxta possession ...
there were certainly a lot of cocks crowing during those spiritual times in the (de)basement of that building at Emporia ... no wonder I didn't learn much there ... the corpse coordinators were too busy getting it on with all the willing corps trainees ...
honorable 9th corp my arssse ... can we put that to a vote?
edited to ask .. between donna and craig and john and pat ... how many corpse were screwed in the basement apartments there in that year of living in the flesh spirit? You can add Dave and Judy in uncle hairy if you want .. not sure about them ...
The audacity for this person to claim to have any kind of ministry is mind boggling ... are people still buying this tripe?
Sorry John ... but go get a real job ... go play basketball, do your comedy schtick ... anything but pretend to be a spiritual guru ... this is disgusting ...
I'm not sure where the drug reference comes from ... is this inside info?
Chemicals can really alter a person .. or maybe help them ...
I see enough problems without claims that it is due to chemicals ... is that evident somehow that i am missing?
Anyway ... the "I am special so the world is out to get me" syndrome is pretty classic ... I'd say more but THEY are listening and THEY want to silence my special knowledge of ALL things ...
gotta go .. THEY are outside now ... please send MONEY ...
Well looks like another satisfied customer.who can seperate the teaching from the teacher
not sure what his current job is .. I just see what he is pushing ...
he didn't separate the teaching very well when he was practicing his learned spiritual acumen in the basement as corps coordinator ... did he?
so vic taught adultery was fine .. and john , while corps cord', acted as though adultery was fine ... when exactly did he learn to separate the teaching from the teacher?
Or which teaching do you mean exactly?
John was a satisfied customer I guess .. he was satisfied with every corps woman he bedded, per VP's teaching .. is that what you mean dove?
The letter of Assumptions--by St. John the divine of Indiana
This is what happens when people isolate themselves from the Christian community at large. No accountibility.
John, get out there and meet some of the Christian youth today. If you can catch them off the missions field or in-between building houses for low income people.
That is if you can catch them in-between ministering to the sick==or raising money for persecuted Brethren.
Go to a reputable Bible College and speak with any freshmen. Bet he/she could give you a run for your money.
We were never better, or smarter, or more "Spiritual" than anyone.
We were duped. Stealing Dale Carnegie, EW Bulliger, and EG Leonard does not a biblical "research" ministry make.
Hasn't this all caused enough pain and suffering?
Quit trying to lead people astray---What's the matter? TWI lite run out of personal prophecy?
DEDICATED TO JALVIS...........A FAITHFUL SON OF HIS "FATHER-IN-THE-WORD"..............FOR HAVING COME FULL CIRCLE, AND JOINING THE RANKS OF HIS FELLOW, LOYAL, SELF-DELUDED, SELF-OBSESSED, AND SELF-RIGHTEOUS VIC APOLOGISTS!..............CONGRATULATIONS, PILGRIM!..............YOUR SEARCH HAS ENDED, RIGHT WHERE IT BEGAN!............I GUESS SELLING PERSONAL PROPHECIES IS'NT AS LUCRATIVE AS IT USED TO BE, EH?............SO, LIKE A DOG RETURNING TO ITS VOMIT, YOU'RE BACK TO SQUARE ONE!!.................................PEACE.
Nostalgia for the "good old days??" I wonder why these guys are so reluctant to really OPEN THEIR EYES and get honest with themselves?? Do they think they will melt if they admit that it's time to pull the plug on the teaching of VPW???
We were all duped, conned, and robbed of many years, but "that which doesn't break us makes us stronger." A cult formed from a ROTTEN ROOT cannot be anything but rotten. Even if you tweak and repackage it, the foundation is still of sand.
This idea that TWI "stands out on the spectrum of Church history as an amazingly significant Christian movement" is just the opinion of one [himself] in his letter. Has anyone ever read a statement like that from someone who was outside of TWI??
I think not, but there are a multitude of statements completely opposite of that opinion. The converse statements are from the wounded, the children of the wounded, as well as counselors, psychiatrists, and pastors who helped the wounded.
VPW, LCM, HA, etc., left a legacy of abuse, mental torture, and dispair. And VPW checked out first leaving his wife and children to bear the brunt of his legacy.
not sure what his current job is .. I just see what he is pushing ...
he didn't separate the teaching very well when he was practicing his learned spiritual acumen in the basement as corps coordinator ... did he?
so vic taught adultery was fine .. and john , while corps cord', acted as though adultery was fine ... when exactly did he learn to separate the teaching from the teacher?
Or which teaching do you mean exactly?
John was a satisfied customer I guess .. he was satisfied with every corps woman he bedded, per VP's teaching .. is that what you mean dove?
No change of point,. it was a silly possibility, given that what people told me as I have repeatedly said did not equal following like sheep. I was never one that lamented about being controlled. So the obvious answer to the question was No.
Nice attempt at switching the subject to some straw man scenario that you pulled ou of thin air. The subject was Johns letter and returning to the subject you will see that from such statements in the letter as
If you once sat through PFAL, you heard the Word of God taught more accurately than the vast majority of Christians who have ever drawn breath.
And ...... That is why The Way International stands out on the spectrum of Church history as an amazingly significant Christian movement.
One can see that indeed he like many others was able to separate the two issues of the teacher and the teaching and that despite some faults of the teacher the teaching is not made void.
This is what happens when people isolate themselves from the Christian community at large. No accountibility.
John, get out there and meet some of the Christian youth today. If you can catch them off the missions field or in-between building houses for low income people.
That is if you can catch them in-between ministering to the sick==or raising money for persecuted Brethren.
Go to a reputable Bible College and speak with any freshmen. Bet he/she could give you a run for your money.
We were never better, or smarter, or more "Spiritual" than anyone.
Recommended Posts
Top Posters In This Topic
19
20
16
25
Popular Days
Jul 3
36
Jul 2
32
Jul 1
23
Aug 8
21
Top Posters In This Topic
Tzaia 19 posts
Ham 20 posts
rhino 16 posts
doojable 25 posts
Popular Days
Jul 3 2008
36 posts
Jul 2 2008
32 posts
Jul 1 2008
23 posts
Aug 8 2008
21 posts
Popular Posts
geisha779
The letter of Assumptions--by St. John the divine of Indiana This is what happens when people isolate themselves from the Christian community at large. No accountibility. John, get out there and mee
geisha779
Word Wolf--That. . . was. . . an. . . AWESOME read!! Thank-you for that effort. Astute very astute!
doojable
I only have a few minutes, (home on a lunch break) but a cursory reading sent up some major red flags.
It sounds like he's doing damage control. This quote seemed odd to me:
Is the same letter that JAL penned with JS, RD and some others? If so then he's being dishonest.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Twinky
This does not ring with compassion or sincere apology, but rather, with same-old, same-old.
Very much like damage control. No acknowledgment of plagiarism, just that TWI pointed the way.
And this: "The Way International stands out on the spectrum of Church history as an amazingly significant Christian movement." Time will tell. How significant will it be in 100 years time? Still it seems that TWI is getting the glory - not God.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
bfh
In the 2008 letter posted on the Web there's a link to the 1998 letter to which JAL is referring and was indeed written by him.
In it he discusses the 1987 letter that was written in conjunction with RD, TR, RB, and PL:
In February of 1987, in conjunction with Ralph Dubofsky, Tom Reahard, Robert Belt and my wife Pat, I participated in writing a 37-page letter that we sent first to the Trustees. In it we confronted them with God's Word as to where they were in error, and called for a meeting of leadership to get out in the open and resolve them biblically.
Here's the link to the 1998 letter:
http://www.christianeducational.org/monthl.../misc/index.htm
I only excerpted parts of the 2008 letter and in the whole letter he does acknowledge plagiarism, along with other abuses:
But, it's like a head nod to the abuses: I [JAL] will acknowledge the abuses, so that I can minimize them and talk about how great VPW and TWI were.
It strikes me as discordant - that's why I'm not sure what to make of it.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
excathedra
I think I'll pass on reading the whole letter.
And WHY is he doing drugs at this point in his life? Isn't he in his 60s?
Link to comment
Share on other sites
mstar1
I read what was posted and ...
Link to comment
Share on other sites
doojable
Agreed mstar.
I skimmed the letters - I couldn't make myself read them in their entirety. They still read like infomercial scripts, IMHO.
"TWI was great! And NOW we have the new, the improved, the best of the best..."
"BUT WAIT! If you act NOW you'll receive not one but TWO sets of Ginsu knives - at no extra charge!"
Also this jumped out at me:
Ummmmm... wasn't JAL one who practiced this error himself?
I'm sorry. I'm just not interested in this "package."
Edited by doojableLink to comment
Share on other sites
rhino
MONEY
... it's a drag ... keep your hand off my stash ...
it is the rooooot of aaawwwll eeevil ... so they saaaay ...
So the plagiarized stuff was the bible as we haven't had it since the first century? Good gawd ...
The business of collecting bucks from ex twi folks is still going?
I wonder if letters like that are valued in how much revenue they bring in ...
are some still longing to "make life meaningful"?
Those are great knives doojable :) ...
but it is a disgrace for me to have been in this fellowship for those knives to have been associated with this rusty old dull doctrine
Edited by rhinoLink to comment
Share on other sites
Thomas Loy Bumgarner
Both John's seem to imply that Bullinger had it mostly correct despite being Trinitarian. JL includes differences from TWI in a link summarizing them with their books and CD's and DVD's teaching series. Both apologize for the sexual abuse that occured but Karen's attitude is not mentioned. In a private post to him, JL said that recent British teaching videos(ALPHA, Open Home/Open Bible, Reality) and materials from the United Methodist(Beginings, Christian Believer) and Saddleback's Foundations 101 are an improvement over what has been taught but still off on the Trinity and Jesus Christ being God disguised in human flesh. He , JS, KG and others from Spirit and Truth, Christian Family, Christian Outreach, Christian Research, and other splinter groups claim it was the filmed PFAL class that forced the denominations to counter it in the late 90's and early 21st Centuary with their "spin". They like the humor and laughter and the personal touch, but still claim that the Church of England, UMC, ELCA, Willow Creek, Lakewood Baptist(Joel Osteen), Saddleback,etc. still don't get it(that is "The Truth"). So much for both John's, Kevin, Wayne, Rochelle and the others. At least they now consider us as the ignorant/separated brethern in the Body of Christ and "tolerate/love" us and no longer want us dead(just misguided like tiny toddlers).ps KG refers to Mr. Gigou, not MS. Grasser.
Edited by Thomas Loy BumgarnerLink to comment
Share on other sites
rhino
Seems they want to inject themselves into the bigger Christian dogma competition scene to create more drama for their soap opera ...
I guess for those that think that is what it is all about .. go ahead and give them more money ...
Link to comment
Share on other sites
mstar1
Thanks for the laugh Dooj..
When I read this--(which is the first thing that made me gag)
juxtaposed against this
I had to wonder what planet he was from, if he was schizophrenic and off his medication ,or if like ex said He started doing some mind altering drugs...Maybe he got bit by hallucinagenic nose spiders hallucinations.
Even if someone somehow was able to stretch and distort history and reality enough to actually believe the first statement how on earth could you state the second one and still maintain the first unless you were severely imbalanced?
If its laden with doctrinal error, practical error, evil, abuse, dishonesty,palgairism and rampant sexual sin ,how can it be a significant christian movement at all, never mind one the most important in history?
Letters like that make me want to pull my hair out
Edited by mstar1Link to comment
Share on other sites
rhino
Wellll ... all great "movements" involve a lot of sheeet ... :)
butt good point mstar ... and nice job of juxta possession ...
there were certainly a lot of cocks crowing during those spiritual times in the (de)basement of that building at Emporia ... no wonder I didn't learn much there ... the corpse coordinators were too busy getting it on with all the willing corps trainees ...
honorable 9th corp my arssse ... can we put that to a vote?
edited to ask .. between donna and craig and john and pat ... how many corpse were screwed in the basement apartments there in that year of living in the flesh spirit? You can add Dave and Judy in uncle hairy if you want .. not sure about them ...
The audacity for this person to claim to have any kind of ministry is mind boggling ... are people still buying this tripe?
Sorry John ... but go get a real job ... go play basketball, do your comedy schtick ... anything but pretend to be a spiritual guru ... this is disgusting ...
Edited by rhinoLink to comment
Share on other sites
frank123lol
Methinks,All these guys(cff ces ect..ad nauseum) are so full of themseves..
I knew(know)kg sg as they were in this area,being "groomed" to be the next family co-ords
His fellowship was like a tigger movie from winnie the pooh.
Last roa happened95 (what a drag that was) next @@boom everthing changes grr meaness
rob sharon m on probation,robm no longer welcome at fellowships..kand s giou33?well..
I was working so I didnot go to that fellowship,kand s raked over the coal badly by who?
Why allan lic@ then lc of michigan,of course his cronie chris gramlic@ nazi extraordinare..
End result?kand s booted,talk to them?you get bootedect.....
Fast forward a few years...I was out of twi pronounced twhy Saw kevin asked him lots of questions..
What do you think of twhy? reponse?they will do thier thing we will do ours,no bitterness,time to move on
come to our fellowships,no discension though,I say where do you come up with that?No response.
I bring this up as sort of history lesson..revere twhy Goes back to herr vic...man of god..
was the word taught? yes,But were we taught?Or were we indoctrinated?
ALot of what I believe today has been re-examined,rethought...
To go back to what js invited,would be the same as twhy cff ces ect..
Link to comment
Share on other sites
bfh
One of the reasons I posted this letter was that it seemed to me, having read the other letters,
that the tone was different, and I was wondering if anyone else thought that also.
In this letter, JAL seemed to be waxing nostalgic about "the good old days" and
now has decided to embrace and vaunt PFAL and VPW.
Maybe it's me, or Mercury is in retrograde, or vertigo from the stock market gyrations today,
but I'm sensing some kind of movement to get back to the "pure" TWI/VPW era. First the Mississippi Farm Corps and now JAL's letter.
I also caught the same illogical thinking as mstar - You grads learned more of the Bible in PFAL than anyone else since the first century,
but there are a few minor doctrinal errors. What? A few? Minor? What?
In fact a lot of the letter made me think - What???
For me, there's a lot of dissonance in this letter.
And on a side note, perhaps JAL's motto has become - Better living through chemistry (or is it chemicals?).
Link to comment
Share on other sites
waysider
Translation
I'm still drinking the kool-aid and and it's tastier than ever.
Won't you come join me in a sip?
Link to comment
Share on other sites
cheranne
new and improved elephant dung! I can smell it from here,just makes me sick.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
rhino
I'm not sure where the drug reference comes from ... is this inside info?
Chemicals can really alter a person .. or maybe help them ...
I see enough problems without claims that it is due to chemicals ... is that evident somehow that i am missing?
Anyway ... the "I am special so the world is out to get me" syndrome is pretty classic ... I'd say more but THEY are listening and THEY want to silence my special knowledge of ALL things ...
gotta go .. THEY are outside now ... please send MONEY ...
(and keep this in your lockbox)
Link to comment
Share on other sites
WhiteDove
I believe he has a real job.........
Well looks like another satisfied customer.who can seperate the teaching from the teacher
Link to comment
Share on other sites
doojable
I agree bfh. That's exactly what struck me.
Here's my question:
IF STFI is soooooo great, why oh why do they need to feed on the carrion of a dead cult?
If they've got this "great package" why do they need to conjure up the memory of der Victoid?
I can hear the violins starting up in the background...
*sniff, sniff* we need money... God needs YOU! Come help us grow!
PUKE
Link to comment
Share on other sites
rhino
not sure what his current job is .. I just see what he is pushing ...
he didn't separate the teaching very well when he was practicing his learned spiritual acumen in the basement as corps coordinator ... did he?
so vic taught adultery was fine .. and john , while corps cord', acted as though adultery was fine ... when exactly did he learn to separate the teaching from the teacher?
Or which teaching do you mean exactly?
John was a satisfied customer I guess .. he was satisfied with every corps woman he bedded, per VP's teaching .. is that what you mean dove?
Link to comment
Share on other sites
geisha779
The letter of Assumptions--by St. John the divine of Indiana
This is what happens when people isolate themselves from the Christian community at large. No accountibility.
John, get out there and meet some of the Christian youth today. If you can catch them off the missions field or in-between building houses for low income people.
That is if you can catch them in-between ministering to the sick==or raising money for persecuted Brethren.
Go to a reputable Bible College and speak with any freshmen. Bet he/she could give you a run for your money.
We were never better, or smarter, or more "Spiritual" than anyone.
We were duped. Stealing Dale Carnegie, EW Bulliger, and EG Leonard does not a biblical "research" ministry make.
Hasn't this all caused enough pain and suffering?
Quit trying to lead people astray---What's the matter? TWI lite run out of personal prophecy?
Go find some widows and orphans to pick on.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
DontWorryBeHappy
DEDICATED TO JALVIS...........A FAITHFUL SON OF HIS "FATHER-IN-THE-WORD"..............FOR HAVING COME FULL CIRCLE, AND JOINING THE RANKS OF HIS FELLOW, LOYAL, SELF-DELUDED, SELF-OBSESSED, AND SELF-RIGHTEOUS VIC APOLOGISTS!..............CONGRATULATIONS, PILGRIM!..............YOUR SEARCH HAS ENDED, RIGHT WHERE IT BEGAN!............I GUESS SELLING PERSONAL PROPHECIES IS'NT AS LUCRATIVE AS IT USED TO BE, EH?............SO, LIKE A DOG RETURNING TO ITS VOMIT, YOU'RE BACK TO SQUARE ONE!!.................................PEACE.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=54qhjlTNVn0...feature=related#
Edited by Don'tWorryBeHappyLink to comment
Share on other sites
Rejoice
Nostalgia for the "good old days??" I wonder why these guys are so reluctant to really OPEN THEIR EYES and get honest with themselves?? Do they think they will melt if they admit that it's time to pull the plug on the teaching of VPW???
We were all duped, conned, and robbed of many years, but "that which doesn't break us makes us stronger." A cult formed from a ROTTEN ROOT cannot be anything but rotten. Even if you tweak and repackage it, the foundation is still of sand.
This idea that TWI "stands out on the spectrum of Church history as an amazingly significant Christian movement" is just the opinion of one [himself] in his letter. Has anyone ever read a statement like that from someone who was outside of TWI??
I think not, but there are a multitude of statements completely opposite of that opinion. The converse statements are from the wounded, the children of the wounded, as well as counselors, psychiatrists, and pastors who helped the wounded.
VPW, LCM, HA, etc., left a legacy of abuse, mental torture, and dispair. And VPW checked out first leaving his wife and children to bear the brunt of his legacy.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
WhiteDove
Link to comment
Share on other sites
mstar1
Thank you Geisha
and also have to say I loved this from DWBH
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.